this post was submitted on 26 Aug 2024
451 points (97.3% liked)
196
16224 readers
3935 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
It actually doesn’t explain anything. Sad reality is she is just a nasty, hateful person. Looking for external explanations is a disservice to acknowledging how prevalent bigotry is.
Devils advocate, ignoring possible outside factors for behavioural changes is also a disservice to acknowledging how prevalent bigotry is, black mould of course over long term exposure would most likely just cause confusion and memory loss, but lead? Lead will fuck your brain right up and send you down all sorts of nasty paths.
Of course she may just be this way, but again, if there is even the possibility for an environmental factor causing degradation into this mindset for a large percentage of the population, it must be addressed or at least considered
If you’re playing devils advocate then you already agree with me and know what my response will be. You’re also being too literal/reductionist with what I’m saying.
No, kindly don't tell me what I'm saying. I'm playing devil's advocate to your comment which said "it actually doesn't explain anything", I'm saying why that statement has no weight behind it.
And who's deciding what's too literal here? You? From where I'm standing it seems like you just didn't like me disagreeing with you. If I'm being too literal may I suggest you're possibly being too emotional and holistic?
Perhaps separate your feelings on the woman and what she's done and look at evidence for possibilities rather than lashing out with a simple absolute like "Sad reality is she is just a nasty, hateful person."
I didn't. The entire reason for playing DA (unless you're being an edgy teenager who doesn't want to be held accountable for what they say) is to provide a counter argument while expressly saying "I don't disagree, I am playing the part of someone who does for the sake of discussion." It is implied you somewhat or mostly agree but are essentially playing a part. So if you actually disagree with me and are trying to have a discussion over that disagreement/opinion you hold, you aren't playing DA.
It seems to me you're just disagreeing while trying to hide behind "well this isn't my opinion" to avoid accountability for what you say next/expressly disagreeing. It's the rhetorical equivalent of having your cake and eating it too.
I will never apologize for calling Rowling a nasty, hateful person while she continues to be a nasty, hateful person. Don't patronize me.
Okay man you're right, have a nice day
You too